Gibbons: Choral and Organ Music
Gibbons is often better represented in the hymn book than in the serious music of a service - and this CD helps demonstrate why that's a shame. With a mix of verse and full anthems, plus both sets of Mag and Nunc, and a smattering of organ music it gives a good picture of Gibbons' church output. If you like the sound of madrigals, you'll like some of the church music, but there are also works in here to rival more heavy duty compositions - Out of the deep, for example. Both evening services are fun - the contemplative verse settings of the second service and the livelier short service.
CDs by St Paul’s Cathedral Choir
There's no doubt that the choir of London's cathedral, St. Paul's, is world class, but they do labour under one problem. The cathedral itself is a beautiful building, but its acoustic is terrible for delicate choral music, with a complex echo that can render the most precise singing a little mushy. To be honest, the choir would do themselves a favour if they recorded somewhere else, but presumably they would see this as letting the side down. Even so, their CDs are often worth buying as they cover some essential music and on the whole do it very well. One other minor criticism - perhaps because of the acoustic they occasional verge on the Victorian in the slowness of their tempos - but they're still a great choir.
Advent at St. Paul's - Choir of St Paul's Cathedral
Advent tends to get overwhelmed by Christmas, so it's a great time to put off the pressure to dive into Christmas music and hear some of the sublime pieces written for the beginning of the church year. With a good mix from ancient to modern, this CD is a refreshing collection. It's not entirely obvious why all the selections are there - the luscious anonymous Rejoice in the Lord Alway (that used to be ascribed to Redford), for instance. But this is top notch church music all the way. As usual, the acoustic at St Paul's makes more for a rich sound than absolute crispness, and tempos are occasionally a trifle slow, but overall up to an excellent standard.
Anon - Laudes Regiae, Palestrina - Matins responsory, Handl - Ecce concipes, Peerson - Blow out the Trumpet
Lloyd - Drop down, ye heavens, Byrd - Laetentur coeli, Wilby - Echo Carol, Weelkes - Hosanna to the Son of David
Britten - Regis regum rectissimi, Anon - Rejoice in the Lord Alway, Gibbons - This is the record of John
Rutter - Hymn to the Creator of Light, Anon - Angelus ad Virginem, Bruckner - Virga Jesse floruit, Parsons - Ave Maria
Palestrina - Vespers responsory, Trad - O come, o come, Emmanuel, Carter - Toccata on Veni Emmanuel
The English Anthem Vol 3 - Choir of St Paul's Cathedral
There is plenty of worthwhile music here in another collection of English anthems from St Paul's. Although as usual the acoustic does give a slight mushiness to the sound, the choir (or director) seems slightly less inclined than usual to adopt slow tempos, which was a pleasant change. Harwood's opening blockbuster with its long organ opening is an acquired taste, reminiscent of Stanford's B flat Te Deum in its ability to be both chirpy and grandiose. Stanford himself weighs in with the even longer The Lord is my Shepherd, not one of our favourites of his output.
These collections tend to be weighted to the Victorian/Edwardian, so it's good to see Tavener's ravishing Hymn to the mother of God, balanced by Walton's equally beautiful piece of the same name. If you like a modern piece, Saxton's At the round earth's imagined corners (the name alone is wonderful) is electrifying. This doesn't mean the older names aren't there, though. Wood classic in Expectans Expectavi is joined by the simple but touching Attwood Come Holy Ghost (soloist isn't brilliant, but is fine). Holst's Turn back, O man, always in danger of sounding plodding, comes across well, and there's a pleasant surprise if you don't know it in Parry's There is an old belief. All in all, a good lucky bag of a CD. Harwood - O how glorious, Stanford - The Lord is my Shepherd, Tavener - Hymn to the mother of God, Wood - Expectans expectavi
Harris - Faire is the heaven, Attwood - Come Holy Ghost, our souls inspire, S S Wesley - In Exitu Israel, Saxton - At the round earth's imagined corners, Walton - Hymn to the mother of God, Holst - Turn back, O man, Parry - There is an old belief,
Elgar - Give unto the Lord (psalm 29)
The English Anthem Vol 4 - Choir of St Paul's Cathedral
A collection of solid English anthems which, despite being 4th in the series manages to include such staples as Attwood's Teach me, O Lord (with its infamous 'the way of thy statutes' that usually comes out as 'statues'), Wood's stately O Thou, the Central Orb, Bullock's Give us the wings of faith and Bairstow's Jesu, grant me this I pray. As usual, mixed feelings about the St Paul's choir - very accurate but, the building's acoustics are mushy and they do love to do things slowly.
Matthias - Let the people praise thee, O God, Bairstow - Jesu, Grant me this I pray, Jackson - Alleluia, laudate puer Dominum
Howells - A Hymn for St. Ceclia, Harris - Bring us, O Lord God, Orr - They that put their trust in the Lord, Stanford - Coelos ascendit hodie
Bullock - Give us the wings of faith, Harvey - I love the Lord, Attwood - Teach me, O Lord, Wood - O Thou the central orb
Grier - Let us invoke Christ, Parry - Hear my words, ye people
My Soul doth Magnify the Lord
If you enjoy those miniature masterpieces, the settings of the Evening canticles, the Magnificat and the Nunc Dimittis, this is an excellent CD to have at the core of your collection with a good set of the best Mag & Nuncs around (even better, also get the companion My Spirit Hath Rejoiced). St. Pauls isn't the idea acoustic for a crisp, precise recording, but there's plenty of verve in the performance to make up for the occasionally excessive echo
Stanford in C, Walmisley in D minor, Wesley in E, Blair in B minor, Wood Collegium Regale (F), Brewer in D
My Spirit hath Rejoiced
A companion to My Soul Doth Magnify the Lord, this is another collection of the settings of the Evening canticles, the Magnificat and the Nunc Dimittis. They've cunningly left several of the best settings for the second CD, so there's no excuse to only go for one, and it continues your collection with a good set of the best Mag & Nuncs around. As before, St. Pauls isn't the idea acoustic for a crisp, precise recording, but there's plenty of verve in the performance to make up for the occasionally excessive echo
Noble in B minor, Howells Gloucester, Murrill in E, Harwood in F, Darke in F, Sumsion in G, Dyson in D
